The Care Economy Comes Due: After the Stabilization Funds Expired, America's Child Care Crisis Became Everyone's Problem
Photo: Globetrotter19, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
When the American Rescue Plan's child care stabilization grants expired at the end of September 2023, the White House warned that more than 3 million children could lose access to care and that tens of thousands of programs faced closure — what the administration and advocates called the 'child care cliff.' Congress chose not to extend the funding. The cliff has since become a plateau of permanent scarcity, and its costs are measured in forfeited paychecks, closed classrooms, and parents — overwhelmingly mothers — working less or not at all.
The Arithmetic of a Broken Market
Child care is a market that cannot clear. Providers must pay wages sufficient to keep workers from leaving for retail and logistics jobs that pay more for less responsibility — yet tuition is already unaffordable for most families. Care costs now exceed in-state public college tuition in much of the country; in several states, infant care runs above $15,000 a year, according to EPI and Child Care Aware state cost reports. Meanwhile, the Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median child care worker wage under $16 an hour — poverty-adjacent pay for work that requires skill, patience, and increasingly, credentials.
This is the rare policy problem where every constituency's interest points the same direction. Parents need care to work. Employers need parents at work. Child care workers need professional wages. The Chamber of Commerce Foundation has itself estimated the child care crisis costs the U.S. economy tens of billions of dollars annually in lost earnings, productivity, and revenue. When the business lobby and the labor movement agree on the diagnosis, the only missing ingredient is political will.
The Federal Floor That Never Came
The Build Back Better Act would have delivered universal pre-K and capped child care costs at 7 percent of income for most families. It died in the Senate. The alternative — a patchwork of expiring grants, oversubscribed Child Care and Development Block Grant funding that reaches only a fraction of eligible children, and state experiments of wildly varying generosity — leaves families to navigate a lottery of geography.
Critics of universal child care raise a fair question: should public money fund care, or should it go directly to families through expanded credits? The strongest version of that argument is about pluralism and parental choice. But the direct-funding answer fails the supply problem — you cannot buy a slot that does not exist. Only public investment builds and sustains the supply side, and it must be coupled with wage standards so that a child care system built on poverty wages is not simply institutionalized.
Who Is Left Holding the Baby
The burden falls hardest on mothers. Research on pandemic-era labor market exits documented that women with young children left the workforce at elevated rates, and post-expiration analyses continue to show maternal employment as the margin on which child care scarcity is settled. It falls on the roughly half of American families who live in 'child care deserts,' per the Center for American Progress. And it falls on child care workers themselves — disproportionately women of color — subsidizing the system with their own poverty.
The Coalition Waiting to Happen
Unions are organizing around it; small businesses are lobbying for it; red-state governors of both parties have requested federal child care funds. The consensus exists. What is missing is a national party willing to make the care economy a first-order electoral issue rather than a line item to be traded away in negotiations.
The verdict: a country that can find money for anything except the care of its children has made a choice — and it is past time to make a different one.